Week 7 in the year of our Lord 2021

The errors that got us here

10 minutes to read

Christians, now is the time to plan, build, and go for it with all your might. Nearly every aspect of human life and culture—from business to vocation to church to home to human sexuality to entertainment to grocery shopping—has gone utterly mad. This is our moment to show the way to sanity, peace, and joy. Don’t quit. Build. —Bryan Sauvé

The past couple of weeks our notes have been full of high-level strategy and exhortation. Basically we want to avoid the revolutionary spirit in favor of a reformational one. We believe that the gospel will leaven the whole lump eventually, and we need to focus on doing our own small part in spreading that leaven, recognizing that we’re in a “freezing” period where yeast really doesn’t grow very well.

We’re leaving autumn and entering winter—but planning for the spring, because there is always a spring.

Even if you don’t share our postmillennialism, we know plenty of premil guys who believe as we do that being overtly Christian is a virtuous cycle. The more people do it, the more people do it. And the more people do it, the fewer people don’t. Since society is made up of people…well, you get the idea. If we want the world to be less secular, we need to stop living in it that way. Optimism about the power of God and his gospel should not be lacking in any Christian.

In coming emails, we are going to start moving down from the high-level view into tactical advice on specific issues, and on making specific plans. In preparation for that, let us give you a summary of some of our thinking at the moment…

How did we get here? #

To effectively play our part in reversing the course of our culture, we need to have some understanding of what that course looked like in the first place.

Much is made every year or two about surveys from high-profile Christian ministries, showing how increasing percentages of evangelicals don’t believe in the inerrancy of Scripture, or the virgin birth, or the deity of Christ, and yada yada yada.

These are serious problems that we don’t want to downplay. But they are also wildly irrelevant in the grand scheme of things—because what isn’t noted on these surveys is the beliefs held for generations by 95% of evangelicals. E.g.:

  • The state should take our money to teach our children.
  • Women should take up duties that Scripture and nature reserve to men.
  • Everyone should get an equal say in how society is run.
  • We should decide what actions are illegal, and what the penalties should be, based on what generally seems right to everyone.
  • When people need charity, the state should be in charge of that.
  • The Bible isn’t relevant to these issues.

The first and last points are intimately related. They form the basis of the accretion disk around the bottomless pit.

In other words, the “new” problems of syncretism, which we are now seeing play out in wokeness, CRT, submission to mask mandates, and the like, are merely late-stage symptoms of a generations-old disease. It is a disease that we’ve forgotten we have, but is terminal if left untreated: the disease of not believing in the sufficiency of Scripture.

All Scripture is breathed out by God, and is profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, for instruction which is in righteousness: that the man of God may be complete, furnished completely unto every good work. (2 Timothy 3:16-17)

You may have heard of Bowdler, who famously edited Shakespeare’s plays to be more suitable for polite society. You may not have heard of Webster, who did the same thing with the Bible. But Western society has, for generations, been advancing Webster’s efforts—by increasingly excising Scripture’s instruction on any topic that puts our nose out of joint.

In an important sense, political correctness and wokeism is just a kind of politeness gone mad—and political correctness and wokeism are just more extreme versions of our long-standing practice of rendering void the Word of God when we find it unmannerly by comparison with our political traditions.

Consider that in a century, we’ve gone from a majority of people recognizing implicitly that men are divinely ordained as the head of the family, to a majority not even recognizing the concept when it is stated explicitly. E.g.:

How did we get here?

There are some issues that we think were particularly key to the decline of the west. This is by no means a comprehensive survey, but from a theological and practical perspective, we have seen these issues work out repeatedly in our own lives, and can see the same patterns in the recent history of the church. We truly do believe that as the church goes, so goes a nation (a simple corollary to the Great Commission).

The general principle is simple: we get the government we deserve. Theology has consequences. So we need to look at the actions that were decisive in getting us where we are, and do the other thing.

Drawing on Matthew 10:16, there are (at least) two broad categories of errors that the church has led our nations into in the past decades:

  1. Lack of innocence. Under this we would place serious missteps like:
    • Reducing the gospel to atonement and justification
    • Thinking that the separation of church and state implies separation of God’s law and state
    • Not loving people enough to tell them the truth
    • Rejecting the goodness of a covenant body and head
    • Choosing what is easy over what is right, even at the expense of our children (e.g., public schooling)
  2. Lack of shrewdness. This would include problems like:
    • Treating repeated bad faith behavior as good faith error
    • Not believing that Shared experience can be a force for evil as much as a force for good
    • Playing by gentlemen’s rules instead of Scripture’s, and assuming the enemy will do the same
    • Thinking that troublemaking and satire are wicked because they are impolite
    • Undervaluing infrastructure
    • Larping instead of fighting

On this final point, can you imagine the church history books a thousand years from now? “So the Church struck back with a coordinated meme attack on the secularist tyrannical government…” Bizarre…and pathetic.

Solutions #

We will delve into each of these issues in future emails, but let us say at the outset that while we are optimistic for the long run, the short-term is going to be challenging.

The deck is stacked against us at every level.

And yet…

  • Haman hung from the gallows that he had prepared for Mordecai
  • The fourth man stood in the fire with the young Israelites
  • Pharaoh’s bones rest in the depths of the Red Sea
  • Blind Samson brought down the temple on the Philistines
  • The tomb of Jesus is empty, and he sits at the right hand of God

All is not lost. Heaven is our home. The enemy cannot rob us of our most precious position: eternity with Christ. Not only this, but if they persecute you and make you suffer, they conform you closer to the image of Christ. And if they kill you, they transform you into the image of Christ.

Hard as this is to internalize, they are literally impotent to do anything except God’s purpose for you.

So fear not, Christian. Be bold. Be faithful.

This is a case of “patriarchy or death.” Let the reader understand.

You can only “out breed” non-Christians if you raise up your children in such a way you don’t lose them to pagan culture.

A fruitful home without a godly culture won’t grow the church.

It will only multiply the number of participants in the “worldly culture.”

It’s not enough to “bear fruit;” you have to also “bring in the harvest.”

Children are arrows in your quiver. Desire many. But know that arrows are worthless when they are bent, twisted, or weak. Better to fashion fewer true shafts than more useless ones.

How do you fashion straight arrows?

Well, here’s how you don’t do it: you don’t give the arrows to someone who has openly told you they intend to make them crooked.

Let us give an analogy: an Englishman wouldn’t send his kids to school in Nazi Germany. An American wouldn’t send his kids to school in Soviet Russia. Yet Christians send their kids to school in the world. Do they not understand that they are at war? Do they not know who the enemy is?

Telling the difference between real blessings, and ease and flattery, can be telling the difference between life and death.

When your battles are online, having online allies matters. When your battles move offline, having offline allies matters a lot more. If you think your battles aren’t going to move offline, you’re not really doing anything worthwhile online.

New content this week #

Bnonn was recently on Stone Mountain Media’s podcast with David Burchard. It was a long and wide-ranging interview. Some things he covered:

  • How he came to faith from being a militant atheist, and met his wife at a swordfighting club.
  • How the religious landscape of NZ is like Fallout 3.
  • Is the covering in 1 Corinthians 11 actually testicles, and what would it imply for inerrancy if so?
  • Symbology is fascinating and difficult.
  • The gospel of the kingdom, and what it means to be a son of God.
  • Whether John Piper is a net positive or negative to the church on gender duties.
  • How Michael saved Bnonn from being a boring red pill negative nancy stuck in a permanent cage stage.
  • Insights from being kicked out of a conservative church for refusing to repent of teaching gendered piety.
  • Former effeminacy and how Bnonn is repenting of it.
  • When should we be willing to vote for a female government official?
  • How spanking in NZ is sort of illegal…sort of.
  • Bnonn’s prophecy for the trajectory of the West; where we are, and where we’ll be in 10 years.
  • Why simplistic prepping is dumb, and how to prepare for the future with confidence.


What’s wrong with Tim Keller, Russell Moore etc #

Some readers were puzzled by our comments on certain Big Eva leaders last week. Here’s something to help you understand what’s up with Tim Keller: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JC8BwvQv6f8&feature=youtu.be

In terms of the others, let us summarize a principle that we’ll talking more about in coming weeks:

Then spake Jesus to the multitudes and to his disciples, saying, The scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses’ seat: all things therefore whatsoever they bid you, these do and observe: but do not ye after their works; for they say, and do not. (Matthew 23:1-3)

Like the religious elites of Jesus’ day, the problem with our “priestly class” is not their orthodoxy. They affirm all the right things.

The problem is something else—something easily detected if we simply learn the basic shrewdness that Jesus instructs his disciples in here.

Notable #

For the sons of this world are more shrewd in their generation than the sons of light. (Luke 16:8)

Q: You’re saying that the reason you acquired a Christian streaming service is because you can take the profits from the Christian movies and retistrubte that to cover your losses on like homosexual, LGBT that sort of thing?

A: Right, exactly. We’re gonna undermine the bigots with their own money <laughs> Not only can we use the profits from the Christians to cover our losses from pushing ideas like LGBT and trans-inclusiveness and diversity, but we can also start to slowly change their movies to be more accepting of what we want them to be accepting of.


Talk again next week,

Bnonn & Michael

This email is archived, but you can receive new ones free every Saturday.

Subscribe to Notes on Manhood

You’ll get the newsletter every Saturday morning, Eastern time.


You’re now subscribed to Notes on Manhood. You will get the next newsletter in your mailbox on Saturday.

You can safely close this dialog and keep browsing now.